Tuesday, February 7, 2017

WestRock Affirms Commitment to Paper – January 2017 M&A Activity

WestRock, the entity created by the merger of RockTenn and MeadWestvaco, enters the new year with a loud and clear affirmation of the company’s commitment to paper-based packaging. In a one-two punch, the company exited the plastic closures and dispensers and landed a solid strategic blow to competitors in the folding carton segment. The company shed its $556 million Home, Health and Beauty business unit in a sale to Silgan Holdings. The divested unit engineers and manufactures triggers, pumps, sprayers and dispensing closure units. Silgan, the acquiring company, manufactures rigid metal and plastic containers as well as the closures and lids. The very next day WestRock acquired Multi Packaging Solutions, the $1.6 billion roll-up of folding carton and high-end packaging companies. 

The acquisition of Multi Packaging Solutions adds considerable depth to WestRock’s strength in the folding carton segment where it already operates vertically, making paper in its paperboard mills, offering design, technical assistance, prepress, and printing to global consumer product companies. The acquired company, established in 2005, private equity-backed Multi Packaging Solutions (MPS) has grown through consistent strategic acquisitions of folding carton, label, packaging design, specialty rigid boxes, gift card; acquiring companies that deliver high-end packaging solutions to the consumer products, personal care and healthcare markets where attractive branding matters. This focused growth strategy paid off when WestRock came calling and offered a price equal to 9.6 times trailing twelve-month adjusted EBITDA.

Wait a minute – did we just say a multiple of 9.6x on TTM? How does what is essentially a printing company achieve an exit multiple approaching double digits when many printers are offered (and accepting) a purchase price of 4.0 times trailing adjusted EBITDA. The key driver of the price paid was very likely the strategic fit that MPS represented for WestRock; simply put there are not many billion-dollar-plus companies in the folding carton segment available for acquisition. When the buyer is as big as WestRock ($14+ billion), it takes a sizable acquisition to move the needle; WestRock was clearly a highly-motivated buyer that was seeking to continue its growth through acquisition. The seller, MPS, was itself a very active acquirer, having recently completed two acquisitions (see The Target Report – November 2016), maintaining its own steady strategic course while showing a very respectable adjusted EBITDA of 14.8%. On the buyer’s side, WestRock enjoys the higher multiple that being a public company endows on successful companies, affording access to capital and the ability to pay more for acquisitions. Commenting on the high multiple it paid, WestRock reported that it expects synergies, savings and improvements that will lower the effective multiple to 7.1 times, but of course that’s speculative and accrues to the buyer only if achieved, while the seller knows they exited at a cool 9.6x multiple.

Commercial Printing – Diversified Services

Pat Patterson, CEO of direct mail and specialty envelope printer Colortree Group, acquired the company he has managed under the ownership of Boathouse Capital since it acquired his company Graphic Innovations in 2011, merging it at that time with another printing company to form the Colortree Group. Boathouse bolted-on a third printing company, Direct Impressions, in 2013, creating the current configuration (see The Target Report – January 2013).

In another successful exit from the printing industry for private equity, Bradford Equities sold Independent Printing of DePere, Wisconsin to trade-only printing company Ennis. The Texas-based Ennis sells exclusively through its distributor network and has executed a disciplined acquisition strategy of adding companies that print products in defined product categories such as bank checks or business forms. With 55 locations across 20 states, Ennis, which reported $544 million revenue, has appeared nine times in our deal logs over the past five and half years. In every transaction, Ennis has executed on its product-focused strategy by acquiring specialty printers: forms (five times), presentation folders, envelopes, tags, labels and promotional products. Independent fits right into the Ennis strategy with defined product offerings including forms, folders and presentation products.

OneTouchPoint, arguably the most viable candidate on the horizon to become the new national roll-up company in today’s commercial printing industry, announced the acquisition of Colorado-based FuseCreates, a commercial printing company that brings additional services, such as mailing, fulfillment, creative and data management to the existing operation in Denver. OneTouchPoint was acquired by private equity firm ICV Partners in 2014 with prior backing from Huron Capital Partners (see The Roll-Up Returns (to Commercial Printing), The Target Report, Sept 2014). The company appears to be accelerating its acquisition activity, having just acquired Cincinnati-based Print Management in November 2016.

Data Communications Management (DCM), based in Brampton, Ontario, announced a double-header with two simultaneous acquisitions, the smaller of which was Thistle Printing, paying $6.1 million for the $16.4 million commercial printer, a ratio of 37% of annual revenue (EBITDA was not disclosed). Announced at the same time, DCM paid $8.8 million for the $21.3 million retail display printing company Eclipse Color & Imaging, a slightly higher ratio of 41% times revenue. Back in the US market, where the market for retail display printing companies has been very robust of late, ColorDynamics of Allen, Texas acquired Superior Graphics, a retail display printing company in Dallas.

Bankruptcies and plant closures spiked up a bit in January, with two Ch. 7 liquidations, four Ch. 11 filings, and five non-bankruptcy closures. None of the bankruptcies filed were by major players and thus the spike may just be a clearing out of some weaker companies as the new year unfolds. One plant closure, however, struck a personal chord; the announcement that Cenveo was closing its Portland plant, formerly The Graphic Arts Center, a super-high-end printer known nationally for printing beautiful annual reports, automotive brochures and fashion catalogs. During the decade before the company was acquired by Cenveo’s predecessor company Mail-Well, I was working for a fine commercial printing company as a sales rep, later as VP of sales and finally as a company owner. On the rare occasion that we were up against The Graphic Arts Center, we knew that in that instance we were not competing on price; we were, at least for the moment, playing in the printing big leagues. They were that good.

2017 January - Mergers and Acquisitions in the Printing, Packaging, Paper & Related Industries  

Deal Party #1
(Surviving Entity)
($Mil )

Party #1 Address

Deal Party #2
($Mil )

Party #2 Address

Deal Structure


Rosebud Media No Data Montreal, QC
Southern Oregon Media Group
(Div. New Media Investment Group)
No Data New York, NY 1/31/17 $15.0 Acquisition Community newspapers Link
New Media Investment Group $1,260 New York, NY
Publishing Division
(Div. Wooster Republican Printing)
No Data Wooster, OH 1/31/17 $21.2 Acquisition Community newspapers Link
Data Communications Mngt. $291.2 Brampton, ON Eclipse Color & Imaging $21.3 Burlington, ON 1/31/17 $8.8 Acquisition Retail display printing Link
Data Communications Mngt. $291.2 Brampton, ON Thistle Printing $16.4 Toronto, ON 1/31/17 $6.1 Acquisition Commercial printing Link
Ennis $544.6 Midlothian, TX  Independent Printing
(Port co. Bradford Equities)
$37.0 DePere, WI 1/30/17 $17.7 Acquisition Folders & forms Link
Baldwin Technology
(Port Co. Forsyth Capital)
$103.7 St. Louis, MO Air Motion Systems No Data River Falls, WI 1/24/17 No Data Acquisition LED UV curing systems Link
ColorDynamics No Data Allen, TX Superior Graphics No Data Dallas, TX 1/24/17 No Data Acquisition Retail display printing Link
WestRock $14,150 Norcross, GA Multi Packaging Solutions
(Port co. Madison Dearborn)
$1,600 New York, NY 1/24/17 $2,280 Acquisition Packaging, folding cartons Link
Silgan Holdings $3,610 Stamford, CT Specialty packaging business
(Div. WestRock)
Norcross, GA 1/23/17 $1,025 Acquisition Closures/Dispensing systems Link
Hearst $10,700 New York, NY The Pioneer Group No Data Big Rapids, MI 1/23/17 No Data Acquisition Community newspapers Link
Tracy Press
(Div Tank Town Media)
No Data Tracy, CA Champion Newspapers No Data Chino, CA 1/20/17 No Data Acquisition Community newspapers Link
Lindenmeyr Munroe
(Div. Central National Gottesman)
$5,500 Purchase, NY KFI Technnology No Data Trenton, NJ 1/19/17 No Data Acquisition Wide format distributor Link
Ricoh $18,040 Tokyo, Japan Avanti No Data Toronto, ON 1/17/17 No Data Acquisition MIS system for printing Link
Colortree Group Mngt Team No Data Richmond, VA Colortree
(Port Co. Boathouse Capital)
No Data Richmond, VA 1/17/17 No Data Acquisition Direct mail printing Link
Nekoosa Coated Products
(Port co. Wingate Partners)
No Data Nekoosa, WI ClingZ No Data Rancho, NM 1/11/17 No Data Acquisition Specialty substrates Link
(Port Co. ICV Partners)
$150 Hartland, WI FuseCreates No Data Denver, CO 1/10/17 No Data Acquisition Commercial printing Link
Deluxe $1,850 Shoreview, MN FMCG Direct $80.0 New York, NY 1/6/17 $200.0 Acquisition
(AGC Partners)
Direct mail marketing Link
Fortis Solutions Group No Data Virginia Beach, VA Action Packaging Systems No Data Ellington, CT 1/4/17 No Data Acquisition Label printing Link
Platinum Equity No Data Beverly Hills, CA Valpak - Cox Target Media No Data St. Petersburg, FL 1/3/17 No Data Acquisition
(Goldman, Sachs)
Direct mail programs Link
Bell and Howell
(Port Co. Versa Capital Mngt.)
No Data Research Triangle Park, NC Sensible Technologies No Data Livonia, MI 1/3/17 No Data Acquisition Mailing services equipment Link

2017 January - Bankruptcy Filings in the Printing, Packaging, Paper & Related Industries

Filing Party

($Mil )

Case #

Filing Party Address


Region & City


Attorney for Debtor

Chapter 11 Filings:
Artful Color, Inc. 1/19/17 No Data 17-00286 Wake, NC 4th Eastern NC
Stephani W.
Travis Sasser  Display & art (giclée) prints
Media Marketing Research, Inc 1/18/17 No Data 17-40204 Long Island City, NY 2nd Eastern NY
Carla E. Craig Stephen Z. Starr  Newspaper & magazine distribution
ColorSciences LLC 1/18/17 No Data 17-10067 Austin, TX 5th Western TX
Tony M. Davis Pro Se Color management systems
Color Resources Center, Inc. 1/11/17 No Data 17-10057 New York, NY 2nd Southern NY
New York
James L. Garrity, Jr.   Julie Cvek Curley Retail display & wide format printing
Chapter 7 Filings:
Pure Exhibits 1/19/17 No Data 17-01593 Oak Lawn, IL 7th Northern IL
Donald R. Cassling John R. Hiltz Trade show exhibits
Miami Valley Publishing LLC 1/18/17 No Data 17-30150 Fairborn, OH 6th Southern OH
Lawrence S. Walter Pro Se Commercial printing

2017 January - Non-Bankruptcy Closures in the Printing, Packaging, Paper & Related Industries

Closed Company / Facility

Date of Closure
($Mil )

Closing Address
Related Party Related Party
Date Closure Public


Cenveo - Printing plant 3/31/17 No Data Portland, OR Cenveo Stamford, CT Jan-17 Commercial printing
Formerly The Graphic Arts Center
Abco Printing  1/24/17 No Data Windsor, NJ None N/A Jan-17 Commercial printing Link
LSC Communications Mar-17 No Data Gallatin, TN LSC Communications Chicago, IL Jan-17 Catalogs & magazine Link
Imprimerie Doublimage 2/22/17 No Data Mascouche, QC None N/A Jan-17 Book printing Link
Shreve Printing 3/3/17 No Data Shreve, OH None N/A Jan-17 Commercial printing Link